Coalition petitions EPA to lower the nitrate limit in drinking water

The filing draws on more than 30 peer-reviewed health studies and a benefit-cost analysis of three alternative standards.

Neoclassical government building with curved facade, tall columns, and manicured courtyard with green landscaping

Smiling man with mustache in blue shirt against deep red background Headshot

A coalition of public health and environmental organizations filed a petition with the U.S. EPA on Nov. 16, asking the agency to lower the federal limit for nitrate in public drinking water from 10 milligrams per liter to 1 mg/L. The current standard was set in 1975 to protect infants from methemoglobinemia, the blood disorder known as blue baby syndrome, and EPA has never updated it. Iowa Public Radio reported the filing, and the coalition announced it in a joint release.

The petitioners are Food & Water Watch, the Environmental Law & Policy Center, the Natural Resources Defense Council, the Environmental Working Group, the Union of Concerned Scientists, the Alliance for the Great Lakes and the Prairie Rivers Network.

What the petition asks

The petition asks EPA for three things: a new maximum contaminant level of 1 mg/L, stronger controls on the farm pollution that puts nitrate into source water, and more federal funding to help public water systems pay for treatment upgrades. 

The filing draws on more than 30 peer-reviewed health studies and a benefit-cost analysis of three alternative standards. By the coalition's estimate, the public health benefits of a 1 mg/L standard would run 3.9 times the infrastructure costs to drinking water providers over the next 50 years.

The science has moved since 1975. Research in the decades since links long-term nitrate exposure at levels below the current limit to colorectal cancer, thyroid disease, neural tube defects and other health effects, Iowa Public Radio reported. The standard has not kept up, the groups say. 

"EPA is using a report from 1962 to set the nitrate drinking water standard," Nancy Stoner, a senior attorney with the Environmental Law & Policy Center, said in the release. "It completely fails to consider the cancer risk associated with drinking nitrate-contaminated water."

Exposure in farm country

The coalition estimates that roughly 1 in 3 Americans, nearly 120 million people, is exposed to nitrate in tap water, and it ties the heaviest contamination to fertilizer and manure from industrial agriculture. In Iowa, the groups say, 46% of residents are exposed to nitrate levels above 1 mg/L. This summer, more than 600,000 Des Moines-area residents faced a second consecutive year of water restrictions, and the metro's nitrate removal systems ran a record 193 days, according to the release.

The petitioners also want EPA to go after the pollution at its source. "Governments can require reporting and establish limits on overapplication of fertilizer and nitrate runoff," J.P. Rose, who leads NRDC's campaign to reduce nitrogen pollution, told Iowa Public Radio. He pointed to cover crops, crop diversification and riparian buffers, and to nitrogen regulations in the European Union and New Zealand.

What happens next

EPA has started and stalled reviews of the nitrate standard several times over the past decade, Iowa Public Radio reported. A petition forces the question. Federal law requires agencies to respond to petitions "within a reasonable time," though it sets no deadline.

"We've put out there the science and the data that shows what the new MCL should be," Tyler Lobdell, a staff attorney with Food & Water Watch, said at a press event.

Pressure has been building. Earlier this year, 83 groups called on EPA Administrator Lee Zeldin and Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. to take emergency action on nitrate pollution from industrial agriculture, and advocates in Iowa, Minnesota, Wisconsin, Oregon and Washington have filed separate petitions seeking emergency protections for private well users, according to the release.